// SPDX-License-Identifier: GPL-2.0-or-later // Copyright (C) 2026 Bryan Joshua Pedini /** * PLAN §12 core items 8 and 10: the Authorization matrix (missing, empty, wrong scheme, malformed, * unknown, near-match, inactive, duplicated, unusual) with exact status, JSON body and headers, * the authentication result class logged at DEBUG, and audit rows only for successes. */ import { test, expect, assertDbInvariants, buildRawRequest, expectContainersResponse, expectErrorResponse, readOperations, type CliRunner, type HttpClient, type RawResult, type ServerHandle, } from '../../harness'; interface Ctx { server: ServerHandle; active: string; other: string; inactive: string; } async function setup(cli: CliRunner, startServer: (o?: object) => Promise): Promise { const active = await cli.tokenNew('active'); const other = await cli.tokenNew('other'); const inactive = await cli.tokenNew('inactive'); await cli.tokenDelete(inactive); const server = await startServer({ logLevel: 'DEBUG' }); server.fakeDocker!.many(1); return { server, active, other, inactive }; } /** Raw request with verbatim header lines. */ function raw(http: HttpClient, s: ServerHandle, headerLines: Array, target = '/api/v1/containers'): Promise { const head = Buffer.concat([ Buffer.from(`GET ${target} HTTP/1.1\r\nHost: localhost\r\n`, 'latin1'), ...headerLines.map((h) => Buffer.concat([typeof h === 'string' ? Buffer.from(h, 'latin1') : h, Buffer.from('\r\n')])), Buffer.from('Connection: close\r\n\r\n'), ]); return http.raw({ host: s.connectHost, port: s.port, data: head }); } function authClasses(s: ServerHandle): string[] { return s.logs().filter({ msg: 'authentication result' }).map((r) => r.attrs.result); } const flipCase = (t: string) => [...t].map((c) => (c === c.toLowerCase() ? c.toUpperCase() : c.toLowerCase())).join(''); test('missing, empty and malformed Authorization headers → 401 (Playwright request)', async ({ cli, startServer, http }) => { const { server, active } = await setup(cli, startServer); const cases: Array<[string, Record, string]> = [ ['no header', {}, 'missing_header'], ['scheme only', { Authorization: 'Bearer' }, 'empty_token'], ['scheme + trailing space (trimmed by HTTP)', { Authorization: 'Bearer ' }, 'empty_token'], ['Basic credentials', { Authorization: 'Basic dXNlcjpwYXNz' }, 'bad_scheme'], ['Token scheme', { Authorization: `Token ${active}` }, 'bad_scheme'], ['bare token, no scheme', { Authorization: active }, 'bad_scheme'], ['tab instead of space', { Authorization: `Bearer\t${active}` }, 'bad_scheme'], ['scheme with colon', { Authorization: `Bearer: ${active}` }, 'bad_scheme'], ['misspelled scheme', { Authorization: `Baerer ${active}` }, 'bad_scheme'], ['scheme prefix', { Authorization: `BearerX ${active}` }, 'bad_scheme'], ['double space before token', { Authorization: `Bearer ${active}` }, 'unknown_token'], ['token followed by extra word', { Authorization: `Bearer ${active} extra` }, 'unknown_token'], ['quoted token', { Authorization: `Bearer "${active}"` }, 'unknown_token'], ['two credentials in one value', { Authorization: `Bearer ${active}, Bearer ${active}` }, 'unknown_token'], ['Bearer Bearer', { Authorization: `Bearer Bearer ${active}` }, 'unknown_token'], ['different header (Proxy-Authorization)', { 'Proxy-Authorization': `Bearer ${active}` }, 'missing_header'], ['token in X-Auth-Token', { 'X-Auth-Token': active }, 'missing_header'], ]; for (const [name, headers] of cases) { await test.step(name, async () => { expectErrorResponse(await http.get(server.url(), { headers }), 401); }); } // query-string tokens are not credentials expectErrorResponse(await http.get(server.url(`/api/v1/containers?access_token=${active}`)), 401); expect((await server.stop()).exitCode).toBe(0); expect(authClasses(server)).toEqual([...cases.map((c) => c[2]), 'missing_header']); expect(readOperations(server.dbPath)).toEqual([]); assertDbInvariants(server.dbPath, { operationCount: 0 }); }); test('empty and whitespace-only header values → 401 (curl and raw socket)', async ({ cli, startServer, http }) => { const { server } = await setup(cli, startServer); // curl: "Name;" sends an empty header expectErrorResponse(await http.curl({ url: server.url(), headers: ['Authorization;'] }), 401); const cases: Array<[string, string, string]> = [ ['empty value', 'Authorization:', 'empty_header'], ['spaces only', 'Authorization: ', 'empty_header'], ['tab only', 'Authorization:\t', 'empty_header'], ['no space after colon, Bearer only', 'Authorization:Bearer', 'empty_token'], ['Bearer + spaces', 'Authorization: Bearer ', 'empty_token'], ]; for (const [name, line] of cases) { await test.step(name, async () => { const r = await raw(http, server, [line]); expect(r.outcome).toBe('response'); expectErrorResponse(r.response!, 401); }); } expect((await server.stop()).exitCode).toBe(0); expect(authClasses(server)).toEqual(['empty_header', ...cases.map((c) => c[2])]); assertDbInvariants(server.dbPath, { operationCount: 0 }); }); test('unknown, near-match and inactive tokens → 401', async ({ cli, startServer, http, rng }) => { const { server, active, inactive } = await setup(cli, startServer); const lastFlip = active.slice(0, -1) + (active.endsWith('A') ? 'B' : 'A'); const cases: Array<[string, string, string]> = [ ['random unknown token', rng.string(43, 'ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZabcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz0123456789-_'), 'unknown_token'], ['last character changed', lastFlip, 'unknown_token'], ['case swapped', flipCase(active), 'unknown_token'], ['one character short', active.slice(0, 42), 'unknown_token'], ['one character extra', active + 'A', 'unknown_token'], ['base64 std alphabet variant', active.replaceAll('-', '+').replaceAll('_', '/'), active.includes('-') || active.includes('_') ? 'unknown_token' : 'ok'], ['padded with =', active + '=', 'unknown_token'], ['percent-encoded first char', '%' + active.charCodeAt(0).toString(16) + active.slice(1), 'unknown_token'], ['SQL injection', `' OR '1'='1`, 'unknown_token'], ['SQL wildcard', '%', 'unknown_token'], ['inactive (deleted) token', inactive, 'inactive_token'], ['inactive token, case swapped', flipCase(inactive), 'unknown_token'], ]; let oks = 0; for (const [name, token, cls] of cases) { await test.step(name, async () => { const r = await http.get(server.url(), { token }); if (cls === 'ok') { expectContainersResponse(r); oks++; } else expectErrorResponse(r, 401); }); } expect((await server.stop()).exitCode).toBe(0); expect(authClasses(server)).toEqual(cases.map((c) => c[2])); expect(readOperations(server.dbPath)).toHaveLength(oks); assertDbInvariants(server.dbPath); }); test('accepted forms: case-insensitive scheme, header-name case, surrounding whitespace → 200 and audited', async ({ cli, startServer, http }) => { const { server, active, other } = await setup(cli, startServer); const pw: Array<[string, Record, string]> = [ ['canonical', { Authorization: `Bearer ${active}` }, active], ['lower-case scheme', { Authorization: `bearer ${active}` }, active], ['upper-case scheme', { Authorization: `BEARER ${other}` }, other], ['mixed-case scheme', { Authorization: `bEaReR ${other}` }, other], ['lower-case header name', { authorization: `Bearer ${active}` }, active], ]; const audited: string[] = []; for (const [name, headers, tok] of pw) { await test.step(name, async () => { expectContainersResponse(await http.get(server.url(), { headers })); audited.push(tok); }); } const rawCases: Array<[string, string, string]> = [ ['trailing spaces trimmed by HTTP parsing', `Authorization: Bearer ${active} `, active], ['trailing tab trimmed', `Authorization: Bearer ${active}\t`, active], ['leading whitespace before scheme trimmed', `Authorization: Bearer ${other}`, other], ['UPPER-CASE header name', `AUTHORIZATION: Bearer ${other}`, other], ['no space after colon', `Authorization:Bearer ${active}`, active], ]; for (const [name, line, tok] of rawCases) { await test.step(name, async () => { const r = await raw(http, server, [line]); expectContainersResponse(r.response!); audited.push(tok); }); } // curl expectContainersResponse(await http.curl({ url: server.url(), token: active })); audited.push(active); expect((await server.stop()).exitCode).toBe(0); expect(authClasses(server)).toEqual(audited.map(() => 'ok')); expect(readOperations(server.dbPath).map((o) => o.token)).toEqual(audited); assertDbInvariants(server.dbPath, { operationCount: audited.length }); }); test('duplicated and conflicting Authorization headers → 401 (multiple_headers), never audited', async ({ cli, startServer, http }) => { const { server, active, other, inactive } = await setup(cli, startServer); const curlCases: Array<[string, string[]]> = [ ['same valid header twice', [`Authorization: Bearer ${active}`, `Authorization: Bearer ${active}`]], ['two different valid tokens', [`Authorization: Bearer ${active}`, `Authorization: Bearer ${other}`]], ['valid + invalid', [`Authorization: Bearer ${active}`, 'Authorization: Basic Zm9vOmJhcg==']], ['invalid + valid', ['Authorization: Bearer nope', `Authorization: Bearer ${active}`]], ['valid + empty', [`Authorization: Bearer ${active}`, 'Authorization;']], ['valid + inactive', [`Authorization: Bearer ${active}`, `Authorization: Bearer ${inactive}`]], ]; for (const [name, headers] of curlCases) { await test.step(`curl: ${name}`, async () => { const r = await http.curl({ url: server.url(), headers }); expect(r.exitCode).toBe(0); expectErrorResponse(r, 401); }); } await test.step('raw: three headers with different name case', async () => { const r = await raw(http, server, [`authorization: Bearer ${active}`, `Authorization: Bearer ${active}`, `AUTHORIZATION: Bearer ${active}`]); expectErrorResponse(r.response!, 401); }); expect((await server.stop()).exitCode).toBe(0); expect(authClasses(server)).toEqual([...curlCases.map(() => 'multiple_headers'), 'multiple_headers']); expect(readOperations(server.dbPath)).toEqual([]); }); test('unusual but syntactically valid Authorization values → 401 without leaking anything', async ({ cli, startServer, http }) => { const { server, active } = await setup(cli, startServer); const cases: Array<[string, Buffer | string, string]> = [ ['very long token (16 KiB)', `Authorization: Bearer ${'A'.repeat(16 * 1024)}`, 'unknown_token'], ['UTF-8 bytes in token (obs-text)', Buffer.concat([Buffer.from('Authorization: Bearer '), Buffer.from('tökén-ü', 'utf8')]), 'unknown_token'], ['Cyrillic look-alike scheme', Buffer.concat([Buffer.from('Authorization: B'), Buffer.from('е', 'utf8'), Buffer.from(`arer ${active}`)]), 'bad_scheme'], ['Latin-1 NBSP instead of space', Buffer.concat([Buffer.from('Authorization: Bearer\xa0', 'latin1'), Buffer.from(active)]), 'bad_scheme'], ['token followed by more words', `Authorization: Bearer ${active} x`, 'unknown_token'], ]; for (const [name, line] of cases) { await test.step(name, async () => { const r = await raw(http, server, [line]); expect(r.outcome).toBe('response'); expectErrorResponse(r.response!, 401); }); } // Control characters (other than HTAB) are invalid in field values: Go rejects the request // with a plain-text 400 before the application sees it (not logged, not audited). for (const ctl of ['\x7f', '\x01', '\x1b']) { await test.step(`control character ${JSON.stringify(ctl)} in the token → Go 400`, async () => { const r = await raw(http, server, [`Authorization: Bearer ${active.slice(0, 20)}${ctl}${active.slice(21)}`]); expect(r.response!.status).toBe(400); expect(r.response!.header('content-type')).toBe('text/plain; charset=utf-8'); }); } expect((await server.stop()).exitCode).toBe(0); expect(authClasses(server)).toEqual(cases.map((c) => c[2])); expect(server.logs().requests(), 'Go-rejected requests are not logged').toHaveLength(cases.length); expect(readOperations(server.dbPath)).toEqual([]); expect(server.stderr).not.toContain('AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA'); }); test('requests on non-endpoint routes and methods are not authenticated or audited even with a valid token', async ({ cli, startServer, http }) => { const { server, active } = await setup(cli, startServer); expectErrorResponse(await http.get(server.url('/api/v1/containers/'), { token: active }), 404); expectErrorResponse(await http.fetch(server.url(), { method: 'POST', token: active }), 405); expectErrorResponse(await http.fetch(server.url(), { method: 'DELETE', token: 'garbage' }), 405); const r = await http.raw({ host: server.connectHost, port: server.port, data: buildRawRequest({ method: 'HEAD', target: '/api/v1/containers', headers: [`Authorization: Bearer ${active}`] }) }); expectErrorResponse(r.response!, 405, { head: true }); expect((await server.stop()).exitCode).toBe(0); expect(authClasses(server), 'authentication never ran').toEqual([]); expect(readOperations(server.dbPath)).toEqual([]); });